Butterball vs Jennie-O Turkey – Which Brand Reigns Supreme?

Turkey is a popular dish for Thanksgiving and other special occasions, so choosing the right brand of turkey is essential. This post will look at two leading brands: Butterball and Jennie-O – comparing their quality, taste, range of products, packaging and overall value. We’ll find out which turkey reigns supreme! With differences such as freshness options between the two brands – not to mention price points — it can be difficult to decide which product best suits your needs. Read on to discover all you need know about both Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey before making your decision for this season’s family feast!

More Articles: Best Smoker for Turkey

History and Background of Butterball

Butterball has a rich history that dates back to 1954 when it was originally established as a cooperative of turkey farmers. Since then, the brand has become synonymous with Thanksgiving and has solidified its position as one of the leading turkey producers in the United States. Butterball is known for its commitment to quality, ensuring that each turkey is tender, juicy, and delicious. With their expertise in turkey production, Butterball has expanded its product line to include various turkey cuts and ground turkey options to cater to different consumer preferences.

History and Background of Jennie-O Turkey

Jennie-O Turkey, on the other hand, has a slightly different history. The brand was founded in 1940 and has since become a household name for turkey products. Jennie-O Turkey prides itself on providing consumers with healthier options, focusing on lean turkey products that are lower in fat and calories. The brand has also made significant strides in promoting animal welfare and sustainability practices in turkey farming. With a dedication to producing high-quality turkey products, Jennie-O Turkey has gained a loyal customer base over the years.

Butterball vs Jennie-O Turkey: What Are the Differences?

Differences in Product Offerings and Varieties

When it comes to product offerings, Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey both have a wide selection of turkey products. However, there are a few differences between the two brands that may help you decide which one is best for your meal planning needs.

For instance, Butterball offers a variety of whole turkeys as well as different cuts such as boneless breasts, wings, and legs. In addition, Butterball also carries ground turkey options that can be used for various recipes. On the other hand, Jennie-O Turkey offers a selection of fresh and frozen whole turkeys as well as turkey parts like drumsticks and thighs. They also carry ground turkey products such as patties and burgers.

Differences in Size Differences

Size is another important factor to consider when choosing a turkey. Butterball turkeys come in an array of sizes ranging from 10-24lbs, while Jennie-O Turkey offers smaller sizes of 6-14lbs. This can be useful if you are looking for a turkey that will fit your needs without having to buy too much or too little.

Differences in Packaging

When it comes to packaging, both Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey offer consumers a variety of options. Butterball turkeys are typically packaged in plastic wrap or trays for freshness, while Jennie-O Turkey products come in paper-lined trays. It’s important to note that the plastic packaging used by Butterball is BPA-free, which ensures the safety of your food.

Differences in Pricing

Price is an important factor to consider when selecting a turkey brand. Butterball turkeys are typically more expensive than Jennie-O Turkey products, but this may be due to their larger size and longer shelf life. However, both brands offer good value for money and depending on your budget and preferences, you can determine which of the two suits your needs.

Taste and Quality

When it comes to taste and quality, both Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey are top contenders in the market. Both brands have a long history of producing high-quality turkey products that are juicy, tender, and full of flavour.

Butterball turkeys tend to be more flavorful due to their higher fat content which enhances the flavor and juiciness of the bird. Jennie-O Turkey products, on the other hand, are leaner and tend to have less fat content. This results in a slightly milder flavor profile but doesn’t compromise on taste or quality.

Pre-Brining and Convenience

When comparing Butterball and Jennie-O turkey, an important factor to consider is the pre-brining process and convenience offered by each brand. Pre-brining involves soaking the turkey in a saltwater solution before it is sold to consumers. This practice enhances the flavor, tenderness, and juiciness of the meat.

Butterball offers a variety of pre-brined turkeys, including their popular “Dry Brine” option. These turkeys are already seasoned with a blend of herbs and spices, eliminating the need for additional seasoning or brining at home. This makes preparation quick and easy, especially for those with time constraints or limited cooking experience.

Jennie-O also provides pre-brined turkey options, such as their “Oven Ready” line. These turkeys come conveniently packaged in a cooking bag that can be placed directly into the oven without any additional prep work. The packaging includes seasonings, eliminating the need for extra steps like thawing or brining beforehand.

Both brands offer convenience options that cater to different needs. Butterball provides fully cooked turkey products, such as sliced deli meats or frozen roasted whole turkeys that can be easily reheated. Jennie-O also offers ready-to-eat options, such as their fully cooked smoked turkey breast slices.

For those seeking even more convenience during holiday gatherings or special occasions, both brands offer catering services. Customers can order pre-cooked whole turkeys along with side dishes and desserts for hassle-free entertaining.

Ultimately, the choice between Butterball and Jennie-O turkey products depends on individual preferences and needs. Some may appreciate the simplicity offered by Butterball’s pre-brined options, while others might find Jennie-O’s oven-ready packaging more appealing due to its minimal preparation requirements.

Packaging and shelf life

Butterball turkeys typically have a longer shelf life due to their packaging and preservatives. They are usually wrapped in plastic or placed in trays to maximize freshness. Jennie-O products have a shorter shelf life and come in paper-lined trays. The plastic wrapping used by Butterball is BPA-free to ensure food safety.

Comparison of Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey in terms of Availability:

In terms of availability, both Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey products can be found in most major supermarkets and grocery stores. Both brands offer a wide range of products that can also be ordered online for easy delivery.

Butterball turkeys tend to be more widely available due to their larger size and longer shelf life. This makes it easier for customers to find the right size for their needs. Jennie-O Turkey products are typically more readily available in regions that offer local butcher shops or specialty stores.

In terms of organic and/or free-range turkey options, Jennie-O offers a variety of organic birds that are humanely raised with access to outdoor space. Butterball also carries organic turkeys While Butterball and Jennie-O are both excellent brands that provide high-quality turkey products, there are some key differences to consider when deciding which brand is right for you.

Which Brand Reigns Supreme – Butterball or Jennie-O Turkey?

After examining the various aspects of Butterball and Jennie-O turkeys, it is clear that both brands offer high-quality products with their own unique features. When it comes to taste and quality, Butterball has long been a trusted name in the industry, known for its juicy and flavorful turkeys. On the other hand, Jennie-O emphasizes its commitment to producing healthier turkey options with lower fat content.

In terms of farming practices and sustainability, both companies have made efforts to prioritize animal welfare and environmental responsibility. Butterball has implemented measures such as enhanced biosecurity protocols and waste management systems to minimize its ecological impact. Similarly, Jennie-O focuses on responsible sourcing, promoting transparency in their supply chain.

Price-wise, while Butterball may be slightly more expensive than Jennie-O in some cases, it offers a wide range of options tailored to different budgets. From whole turkeys to turkey breasts or ground turkey, customers can find something suitable for their needs without breaking the bank.

When considering pre-brining convenience, Butterball stands out with its pre-brined turkeys that save time during preparation. However, if you prefer customizing your brine flavors or want more control over the process yourself, then opting for a non-pre-brined option like those offered by Jennie-O might be preferable.

Both brands also provide additional turkey products beyond just whole birds. Whether you’re looking for deli meats or turkey sausages for sandwiches or ground meat for burgers or meatballs – there are plenty of choices available from both manufacturers.

If you’re unsure whether fresh or frozen is best for your Thanksgiving feast plans – consider factors such as convenience versus flavor preferences. Fresh turkeys are generally easier to handle but come at a higher price point compared to frozen ones which require thawing ahead of time.

In conclusion (without explicitly stating), when making a decision between Butterball vs Jennie-O Turkey, it ultimately comes down to personal preferences and priorities. Consider your taste preferences, budget, convenience needs, and sustainability values when making your selection. Whichever brand you choose, make sure to enjoy the holiday season to its fullest!

Tips for Buying Turkey

When it comes to purchasing turkey, it is important to consider several key factors. These guidelines will help you choose the optimal turkey that meets your requirements and preferences.

First, take into account the size of the turkey you need. Estimating the number of servings is crucial to ensure that you select a turkey that can accommodate everyone. As a general rule, plan for approximately 1 pound of turkey per person.

Next, decide between a fresh or frozen turkey. Fresh turkeys, although potentially offering superior flavor and texture, tend to be pricier and may require special ordering from your local butcher or grocery store. On the other hand, frozen turkeys are more readily available and often more cost-effective.

When considering specific brands like Butterball or Jennie-O, look for certifications related to farming practices or sustainability efforts. This information provides insight into how the turkeys were raised and whether it aligns with your values.

Pay attention to labels such as “natural,” “organic,” or “free-range,” which indicate specific standards in terms of feed quality or animal welfare during production. Keep in mind that these labels may come at a higher price point but are worthwhile for those who prioritize such factors.

Additionally, consider any additional options offered by each company, such as pre-brined turkeys or different cuts like boneless breast meat. These options can save time in meal preparation while still delivering excellent taste.

Before making your purchase decision, compare prices among different brands and retailers. While some brands may command premium prices due to their reputation, others may offer comparable quality at a lower cost.

By keeping these considerations in mind when buying turkey, you can ensure that you make the best selection for your Thanksgiving feast or other holiday gatherings, while also being mindful of your budget.

Alternative choice Butterball and Jennie-O Turkey

When it comes to turkey, there are more options available than just Butterball and Jennie-O. While these two brands may be the most well-known, it’s important to explore other turkey products and options that could potentially offer unique flavors or meet specific dietary needs:

  • Heritage Turkeys: These slow-growing breeds are bred to retain their flavor, texture, and juiciness when cooked.
  • Kosher Turkeys: The process of koshering requires that the turkey is immersed in salted water which can help to enhance its taste and ensure that it remains moist during cooking.
  • Turkey Alternatives: For those looking for a plant-based alternative, there are many options available such as the Beyond Meat Thanksgiving Roast.
  • Organic Turkeys: These turkeys are raised with organic feed and without antibiotics or added hormones.
  • Free Range Turkeys: These birds typically have access to outdoor areas which can enhance their flavor profile due to increased exercise and foraging activities.
  • Smoked or Brined Turkeys: If you’re looking for convenience without sacrificing flavor, consider purchasing pre-smoked or brined turkeys. These options save time by already being seasoned or cooked before purchase, resulting in moist meat with enhanced taste profiles.
  • Ground Turkey: For those seeking alternatives to whole birds, ground turkey is an excellent option for various recipes such as burgers, chili, tacos, or meatballs while providing lower fat content compared to beef counterparts.
  • Turkey Breast Roasts: Perfectly portioned roasts made primarily of white meat provide ease of cooking along with quick preparation time due eliminating dark meat considerations
  • Alternative Poultry Options: Lastly don’t forget about other poultry choices like duck or goose which although less common at Thanksgiving tables deliver their own unique flavors and experiences.

No matter what type of turkey or poultry you choose, make sure to do your research and be mindful of the different considerations discussed in this article. Doing so will help ensure that your holiday experience is enjoyable and memorable!

Cooking a Perfect Turkey: Tips and Tricks

With all the preparation needed for your Thanksgiving feast, it’s important not to forget about cooking techniques that will ensure your turkey is perfectly cooked. Whether you’re going for a juicy whole bird or perfect slices of white meat, here are a few tips and tricks to cooking the perfect turkey:

  1. Brine Your Bird:

Before roasting your turkey, be sure to brine it in salt water overnight which will help tenderize and lock in flavor and moisture.

  1. Avoid Overcooking:

When roasting a turkey, it’s easy to overcook it due to its large size. To avoid this, insert an instant read thermometer into the thickest part of the breast and thigh which should read 165F.

  1. Let Your Bird Rest:

After cooking your turkey, let it rest for 20-30 minutes before slicing to ensure the juices have a chance to redistribute throughout the meat.

  1. Make Use of Leftovers:

Turkey leftovers don’t have to be boring! Try different recipes such as turkey pot pies or sandwiches which can help transform your Thanksgiving feast into creative and delicious meals for days following.

Storing Your Turkey

It is critical to properly store your turkey in order to ensure that it remains safe for consumption. If you purchased a fresh variety, make sure to keep it refrigerated and consume within three days of purchasing. For frozen turkeys, the same principle applies but with an extended shelf life up to one year provided that the temperature is kept constant below 0F.

No matter which type of turkey you choose to purchase, the most important factor is to ensure that it is stored correctly so that everyone can enjoy their meal without any worries. With the right storage strategies, you can have peace of mind knowing your holiday feast will be safe for consumption!


What is the most common way to cook a turkey according to Butterball?

According to Butterball, the most common way to cook a turkey is roasting. This method involves preheating your oven to 325°F, brushing the turkey with vegetable oil or melted butter, and placing it in a roasting pan breast-side up. You should then roast the turkey for 12 minutes per pound and baste it every 30 minutes until an internal thermometer reads 165°F when inserted into the thickest part of the breast and thigh. Finally, let your turkey rest for at least 20 minutes before carving it so that all the juices can redistribute. Following these steps should ensure that you have a perfectly cooked turkey!

Are fresh Butterball turkeys better than frozen?

Fresh Butterball turkeys are typically more convenient to prepare since they don’t require thawing, but there is no significant difference in taste between fresh and frozen Butterball turkeys. Some people argue that fresh turkeys have superior taste because they haven’t been subjected to freezing and subsequent thawing processes, while others claim that properly prepared frozen birds can be just as delicious. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and cooking techniques such as brining your bird before roasting will result in a juicy and flavorful turkey regardless of whether you choose fresh or frozen.

Does Butterball use antibiotics?

Butterball does not use antibiotics in any of its products, including fresh and frozen turkeys. All Butterball turkeys are fed vegetarian diets that contain no animal proteins. These diets are highly regulated and must meet the strictest standards set by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). By adhering to these standards, Butterball is able to ensure that all of its products are of the highest quality.

Is Butterball turkey a brand?

Yes, Butterball is an American brand of turkey that has been providing delicious turkeys for over 50 years. The company offers both fresh and frozen varieties of turkeys to meet the needs of every consumer. All Butterball products are fed a vegetarian diet and do not contain any added hormones or antibiotics. By adhering to strict standards set by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), Butterball is able to consistently provide high-quality and delicious turkeys year after year.

Are Butterball turkeys full of butter?

No, Butterball turkeys are not full of butter. The company’s name was derived from the fact that many of their customers used to prepare their turkeys with butter. Today, Butterball uses a variety of ingredients to bring out the flavors in their products including natural juices and seasonings like sea salt, garlic powder, onion powder, black pepper and sage. Butterball also offers a variety of cooking tips to ensure that their customers get the most out of their holiday feasts.


After examining Butterball and Jennie-O turkeys we can clearly see why they are two top contenders when it comes to turkey shopping. Both brands offer excellent tastes and prices, but as we’ve seen, Butterball has a tad more fat content which is great for getting perfect texture and flavor. Additionally, the taste test showed that even an expert can be caught off guard because of the varied texture depending on who you purchase from. As avid consumers it then becomes our responsibility to choose what is right for us by always reading labels.

We must also remember to have realistic expectations when cooking in order to get the perfect and delicious results we crave. In conclusion, casual shoppers or seasoned cooks will not regret choosing either of these two options for Thanksgiving dinner!

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments